AbbyWinters is a true premium amateur porn website with a history and legacy worthy of a medal. Created in 2000 when there were no good amateur XXX content sites, it is still bringing one the best content in the industry after all these years.

Who is Abby Winters? The original creator of the site. She had stepped down from the CEO position in May 2002 while remaining the “behind the scenes” person. Garion Hall, her friend, now runs the site.

#2. Content Breakdown by Categories

AbbyWinters doesn’t have categories but utilizes “fetishes” as well as “subgroups” instead. It’s like a tagging system that is not perfect and includes duplicates (anal dildo, anus asshole, anal sex, all these are separated). So, see the filtering options area for a better look at this site section. You’ll find dirty panties, fair skin, braces, nipple-to-nipple, and all kinds of interesting names.

All Videos (5657)

100%

Solo (2658)

60%

Video Masturbation (1761)

51%

Girl-Girl (921)

42%

Girl-Boy (110)

Guest Direction (38)

#3. First Impressions & User Navigation

Loading AbbyWinters moves you back to the 19th century when the sensible design wasn’t common. It’s rare for us to complain about the premium amateur site’s layout, but I guess this one takes an honor. I could fix everything on my own given the opportunity, so if AbbyWinters owners are reading our review, a few grand there and here shall get you covered. Otherwise, let me just name a few things that are broken or not up to today’s standards.

The most atrocious header of all time is at the top of the AbbyWinters webpage. It’s so large that you can’t see anything else, and no, we are not using 10-inch displays either. In fact, it could very well be buggy because it’s that “odd,” not to mention the outdated featured images with a copyright logo from 2015. How’s that for a first impression? This alone could steer away multiple people away from AbbyWinters onto something else. Now, if you find a tiny “slider arrow” and click on it, some older models might appear. You might want to remember, this is a “featured porn” section, so some visitors might get an impression that their best works are from many years ago. Is this a good strategy? I think not.

The best part of any female isn’t what’s at the top but what’s down below. That’s the case with AbbyWinters, too, because, after another line of selling points, you see nudes! Not just any nudes but trailers that can be downloaded to your computer. Yes, I know that no one does it nowadays because “praise the world of streaming,” but this is such a great thing for me. I feel way more comfortable watching videos on my PC, and AbbyWinters does allow me to do so without any restrictions. Free galleries are also available, so despite a horrible first minute, things are picking up now.

The user navigation, on the other hand, could be clearer. You click the “explore button only to be greeted with weird menu options like browse > fetishes. Oh, those are just categories, right? Wrong. Instead, a random selection of “nonsense” loads that makes my brain boil. Imagine getting rid of best categories or tags like “big ass,” “anal,” “69”, and replacing those with the gibberish of “physical attributes changeable,” “appealing images,” etc. This is horrible! It’s as if an uneducated person designed this section. I advise getting rid of all these weird names and sticking to the basics. Navigating AbbyWinters at first is a hell of a confusing experience that, again, distracts people from good content and prevents them from registering. In fact, I’m so frustrated by this area that it’s time for me to go somewhere else and take a moment to reflect.

My final advice for the creators of AbbyWinters or those navigating the area is to stick with the /members/ area as your default landing page (registration is not required). It uses a basic, well-known layout with the latest video thumbnails, upcoming shoots, filtering options, etc.

#3a. Content Filters

Yes, we’re entering the area of filters, and finally, AbbyWinters picks up the pace again! There are many fantastic ways to sort your content, including “all, solo, girl-girl, girl-boy, intimate-moments,” followed by video or images as well as a search bar. AbbyWinters search bar is one of the best; there is an advanced search option, and the sliders are superior to everything we’ve seen everywhere else. You can use those to search for “lesbian” content from 19-year-old babes who have uploaded scenes from January 2018 to February 2018. It’s that detailed!

The advanced AbbyWinters search introduces subgroups like “nude girls” and “best of,” as well as fetishes. Here, things are a bit complicated with some duplicates, but again, the range sliders will be enough for 99% of your needs.

#4. Video Player & Streaming Experience

No bad experiences with the streaming service, but honestly, just download these videos to your PC. They are DRM-free and are best viewed from the comfort of your home or woods.

#4a. Download Options (40-Minute Video)

You can watch most of the movies in full HD online or download them to your PC; picture galleries are in high resolution, which you can watch online or download ZIPs to your computer.

Medium - 320p - (110 MB)
High - 480p - (250 MB)
HD - 720p - (708 MB)
Full HD - 1080p (1.52 GB)
Ultra Full HD - 2106p (3.01 GB)

#4b. Streaming Options

Auto, 320p, 480p, 720p, 1080p

#5. Video & Audio Quality

HD - 720p (2300 to 2600 kbps)
Full HD - 1080p (4000 to 5000 kbps)
Ultra Full HD - 2160p (10000 kbps)

AbbyWinters audio quality can be either at around 156 kbps, this is the industry average, to be fair, or go as low as 96 kbps. That isn’t good. Yes, the music industry has moved to the 320 kbps or FLAC, but porn sites are still stuck with this. Only AdultTime and/or EvilAngel have been seen using higher bitrate. Thankfully, their 4K content is of nice bitrate.

As far as bitrates go, the video quality is lower than many of its competitors, who are at around 6000 kbps for 1080p porn and 3000 kbps for 720p scenes.

#6. Porn Content & Performers

Their content is a tasty blend of solo as well as regular lovemaking sessions. The former is self-explanatory because you’ve seen people masturbate thousands of times. The same can be said about intimate moments or somewhat more interesting “behind the scenes” clips. So, I wouldn’t be wrong to describe only the clips from the said couple.

As you shall see from AbbyWinters trailers, those videos show amateur names and their relationship status. For example, for how long they’ve been together. This was a “first” for me because often, you watch a video without thinking much about their relationships. AbbyWinters goes the other way, and that’s welcome. Other times, such details are not visible, and you get detailed “talks” for the first 10 to 20 minutes, followed by nudes and then sex.

The sex part is “hot,” but not “pornstar hot.” Like, the moans are here, but those are way more muted than the fake nonsense that you hear everywhere else. There are, sometimes, blasts of passion that lead to beautiful moments. Like the Alexandra's scene where she licked the juices out of her female partner’s pussy, it was freaking hot, and we aren’t even that into lesbian scenes. You’ll have to see to believe, and man, this is the best part of AbbyWinters. You watch legit sex videos. I admit, having given so much hate for the design, navigation, tags, and whatever else is there on AbbyWinters, everything has been redeemed with some of the best, if not the best amateur videos we’ve seen.

Who’s filming videos? A third person; these are no POV uploads, thankfully. Imagine a porn producer from RealityKings entering your home and filming you doing your deeds. That’s how it is here, and this is awesome. As you’ll see from my AbbyWinters review, this section is where I’m praising the studio while hating everything else about it.

#6a. Update Frequency

Over 6,000 videos and photo galleries are combined in the members' area. In addition, you get around 20 new scenes added every month (thanks to frequent updates).

#6b. Porn Directors

For porn director names, you’ll have to go somewhere else. These amateurs go with the flow and aren’t directing anything.

#6c. Pornstars

The people you will see on the website are true amateurs, not a single pornstar. Sex, masturbation, orgasms, and everything else are real; this is not the place for fake feelings; they make real as they should be. AbbyWinters offers a massive variety of models. Amateurs aren’t always 10/10 models, which is fine. They might have body flaws, random tits, whatever. It’s what you've signed up for, right? Solid, no “bs” scenes.

Aside from the looks, you can see all the different people who are in solo girl action, guy-on-girl action, girl-on-girl scenes, and even some glamour content. The male “pornstars” are the same, and if I were to rate a couple’s looks, they would be above average.

#8. Bonus Sites

No sites but two times a week AbbyWinters schedules a free webcam show for you to enjoy. And this is called "playdates." You can also take those girls to private shows, but that's an extra cost.

#9. Conclusion

All in all, this is a quality, top-notch premium amateur porn website. Members will enjoy real sex, real orgasms, and authentic amateur models, just with not the best lighting or camera equipment. Also, I wish there were more porn and not solo videos. The design, on the other hand, portrays AbbyWinters as a bland studio. Still, we are excited and horny for more raw amateur action. The quality points are here for the amateur work, not bitrates. It would be a ten if there were more couple videos and a little of the solo boredom.

8.5 Total Score

Great Videos Wrapped in a Dull Package

Let’s start unwrapping, gentlemen.

Content Quality

Content Quantity

6.5

Update Frequency

Site Features

Visit AbbyWinters