My Babysitters Club review

My Babysitters Club

The Good
  • Comes for free with TeamSkeet
  • Surprisingly interesting plots
  • Features famous teen babes
  • Has many other bonus sites
  • Feature rich user interface
  • Also includes amateurs
  • Great video quality
  • Strong performers
  • Includes galleries
  • Fast downloads
  • Mobile Support
The Bad
  • Slow to load tags sidebar
  • Has some ugly women
  • Needs more content
  • No longer updating
Site not working? Report!
  • Number of Videos: 67
  • Pornstars: 51
  • Bonus Sites: Part of Team Skeet
  • Last Updated: December 21, 2020

Quick Navigation

#1. About My Babysitters Club

This is a free bonus site of the Team Skeet network. For more details and insights, see our full review.

Pushing uploads since the mid-2015, My Babysitters Club is a teen porn site featuring average to hot looking babysitters and fantasies associated with the niche. Young teen sluts and the multitude of ways in which you can fuck them.

#2. Content Breakdown by Categories

You can view a full list of categories and TeamSkeet niches in our main review. Let’s breakdown the top 10 of this site.

All Videos (67)
Teen (63)
Natural Tits (58)
Caucasian (51)
Amateur (48)
Hardcore (41)
Shaved Pussy (41)
Petite (30)
Couch (29)
18 (28)
Skirts (15)

#3. First Impressions & User Navigation

This has to be one of the most awkward color schemes I’ve seen in a long time. It’s brown and looks awful, like one of the HTML table-based sites from the late 90s or early 2000s. That doesn’t inspire confidence and must be reflecting on TeamSkeet conversion rates. Considering the lack of updates, I doubt that it will be changed anytime soon.

Like in all of the bonus sites, you can watch free trailers of every scene and browse all site pornstars. It doesn’t get better than this because there are no sneaky popups or limitations for the guest visitors. The only downside is a color scheme.

Anyhow, it’s all about the content and functionality, right? The content I will cover in the next section but site features are up to date and plentiful. It’s just the sales page after all. You get interactive thumbnails, decent yet slow filtering system and fresh design on the inside.

There’s also a comment system, galleries as well as screencaps. Unlike few other premium sites, My Babysitters Club doesn’t limit downloads and you are free to grab all the videos the minute your membership is bought.

#4. Porn Content & Performers

Testing the content waters, I’ve found My Babysitters Club to be full of engaging ideas and fun plots. It doesn’t rush with the sex scenes and there’s a slow buildup from the initial meet and greet to something sexual. There’s a nice flow that is not forced. TeamSkeet bonus sites were a hit or miss for me in this regard and My Babysitters Club does it right.

Porn videos are in the range of around 35 minutes, plus minus five. These feature a single take in a static or gonzo camera shots. There are probably at least two producers since most scenes have had a moving cameraman while others stuck for the less traditional, static camera shots. You know, a “spy cam” sort of the videos with some changes in angles.

Let’s talk about porn plots and an overall reality niche engagement. You can’t have a porn site without the classic clichés either. At some point, you’re forced to use them anyway. For example, there was this African American lady who, after around 4 minutes of walking around the house, stole money from her employer. As shocking as it sounds, he caught the teen slut and suggested how can one make even more cash. You know, by eating a dick or two.

There’s a scenario with the peeping Tom who accidentally catches a babysitter changing her clothes. It was 5 minutes into the scene, amplifying my point of a natural flow. Not wanting to spoil the rest, I’ll just say that at least 9 out of 10 videos are worth watching.

The performers for the most part do a good job with very few sluts that have had trouble acting. You can see in their faces that they are trying so hard not to laugh and it ruins the tone. One of such examples is Shae Celestine’s video.

#4a. Update Frequency

There are no new uploads since December of 2017 and that’s a shame. Before that, members got two new videos every month.

#4b. Pornstars

Since there were no new uploads for quite a few years, the pornstars on My Babysitters Club are from the same last decade. You have women like Charity Crawford, Kendall Woods, Kimmy Granger, and Dolly Leigh although they must have appeared before becoming super-famous. They were in the teen years at the time of filming and most pornstars are of similar age. Slim Caucasians dominate the videos with only few Latinas and African Americans thrown into the pot.

Then, you have the outsiders and these sluts are mediocre at best. Just women that don’t inspire confidence due to crooked teeth or other, non-acceptable standards of today’s pornstars.

Male pornstars from the “recent” uploads include Tommy Gunn and Marcus London. They are good for the most part and I did not have much complaints. The site will sometimes throw a bone by giving a few random names too. Only one older (and creepy) guy disappointed me in his acting and surprisingly, he’s not even mentioned in credits. That was a scene with Shae, by the way.

#5. Conclusion

My Babysitters Club has more than a thousand followers on the TeamSkeet network and I have no idea why they stopped pushing new content. Maybe other, also free sites, took them over in popularity and the content creators couldn’t bother?

However, If you’re already a paying member of TeamSkeet, go ahead and download these videos. They are very good! The resolution is still 1080p and there are no outdated quality vibes. Should you join My BabySitters Club for 60+ videos alone? No, at least not for more than a month.

7 Total Score
Top Quality Babysitter Porn

Just without any fresh uploads.

Content Quality
Content Quantity
Update Frequency (All Sites)
Site Features

Teen Porn Sites similar to My Babysitters Club

string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) "" string(17) ""